There are four thermal management solutions for global energy storage systems: air cooling, liquid cooling, heat pipe cooling, and phase change cooling. At present, only air cooling and liquid cooling have entered large-scale applications, and heat pipe cooling and phase change cooling are still in the laboratory stage. Liquid cooling vs air cooling technology have their own advantages and disadvantages, and are also suitable for different application scenarios.
1. What is liquid cooling?
Liquid cooling technology refers to the method of cooling by liquid contact with heat source. According to the different contact heat transfer methods between cooling liquid and server, it can be divided into direct liquid cooling and indirect liquid cooling.Â
Among them, indirect liquid cooling is mainly based on cold plate liquid cooling technology, and direct liquid cooling is mainly based on immersion liquid cooling technology. If you are interested in liquid cooling systems, please check out top 10 energy storage liquid cooling host manufacturers in the world.
The cold plate liquid cooling adopts micro-channel enhanced heat transfer technology with extremely high heat dissipation performance. It conducts heat into the coolant by passing it through a metal cold plate that is in direct contact with the device.
- Liquid cooling vs air cooling
- Advantages: Easy installation, small size, high heat dissipation efficiency, less modification to existing server chip components and auxiliary components, stronger operability, currently the most mature and widely used.
- Disadvantages: Regular maintenance is required to ensure smooth flow of coolant, and cold plates may need to be customized for different equipment, which increases the cost.
The immersion liquid cooling technology immerses the heat-generating device so that the device is in direct contact with the liquid for heat exchange. Among them, the coolant is the heat exchange medium of the data center, which has high insulation, low viscosity and super compatibility, and is the main medium of the immersion liquid cooling technology.
- Liquid cooling vs air cooling
- Advantages: Allows for full heat dissipation, suitable for high power density devices, and has a lower noise level.
- Disadvantages: The installation and maintenance are relatively complicated, and the waterproof performance of the equipment, as well as the cleaning and replacement of the coolant need to be considered.
The basic components of the energy storage liquid cooling system include: liquid cooling plate, liquid cooling unit (heater optional), liquid cooling pipeline (including temperature sensor, valve), high and low voltage wiring harness; cooling liquid (ethylene glycol aqueous solution), etc.
2. What is air cooling?
Air-cooling technology refers to a cooling method that uses low-temperature air as the medium and uses natural wind or fans to generate heat convection with the battery cells, thereby reducing the battery temperature. According to the power source of air flow, air cooling can be divided into natural air cooling and forced air cooling.
Free air cooling uses temperature changes to create air circulation that removes heat. When the air near the energy storage equipment, such as the energy storage container, is heated, the temperature increases and the density decreases, and the hot air rises to the upper part of the data center, creating a pressure difference, so that the cold air flows naturally to the energy storage equipment.
Although natural air cooling has the characteristics of simplicity and energy saving, its air flow rate is small, the convective heat transfer effect is not obvious, the cooling effect is poor, and the energy utilization efficiency is low, so it has been gradually eliminated.
On the contrary, forced air cooling is a technical method in which cold air is forcibly flowed through a fan and blown to the energy storage device for cooling. This method can achieve good cooling performance by increasing the heat dissipation area of the energy storage device or increasing the air flow velocity.
Studies have shown that the energy consumption of forced air-cooled energy storage equipment can be reduced by about 20% by using technologies such as reasonable airflow organization, intelligent ventilation, precise air supply, intelligent heat exchange, cold storage air conditioners, air-conditioning additives, and refrigerant control of air-conditioning compressors. .
- Main components: mainly composed of indoor unit (including compressor, evaporator, expansion valve, etc.) and outdoor unit (condenser, etc.), and the indoor unit corresponds to the outdoor unit one by one;
3. Liquid cooling vs air cooling
In the case of thermal runaway precursors, the liquid cooling vs air cooling solution can rely on a large flow of cooling medium to force the battery pack to dissipate heat and realize heat redistribution between battery modules, which can quickly suppress the continuous deterioration of thermal runaway and reduce the risk of runaway.
At the same time, the liquid cooling vs air cooling, air cooling system has the characteristics of simple system, low manufacturing cost, and easy installation. There are still many applications in the scene where the battery energy density is low and the charging and discharging speed is slow.
From the perspective of cooling effect, Liquid cooling vs air cooling, air cooling has a greater advantage than liquid cooling.
3.1 Liquid cooling vs air Cooling: battery pack temperature
As shown in the figure below, under the same inlet temperature and limit wind speed and flow rate, liquid cooling vs air cooling, the temperature of the liquid-cooled battery pack is 30-40 degrees Celsius, while the temperature of the air-cooled battery pack is 37-45 degrees Celsius. The temperature uniformity of liquid cooling is better.
3.2 Liquid cooling vs air cooling: operating energy consumption
According to experimental research, in order to achieve the same average battery temperature, liquid cooling vs air cooling, air cooling needs 2-3 times higher energy consumption than liquid cooling. Under the same power consumption, the maximum temperature of the battery pack is 3-5 degrees Celsius higher for air cooling than for liquid cooling. Liquid cooling consumes less power.

3.3 Liquid cooling vs air cooling: risk of battery thermal runaway
Due to factors such as the specific heat capacity of air and the small convective heat transfer coefficient, liquid cooling vs air cooling, the heat transfer efficiency of the battery air cooling technology is low, and the heat generated by the battery increases, which will cause the battery temperature to be too high, and there is a risk of thermal runaway; the battery liquid cooling system can greatly reduce the risk of thermal runaway of the battery.
3.4 Liquid cooling vs air cooling: investment in fixed asset
According to the data of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) in the United States, the battery investment cost per kWh of a 4-hour battery energy storage system is currently 1,900 RMB (300 US dollars), and the thermal management system is estimated to account for 2-4% of the battery cost.Â
Liquid cooling vs air cooling, liquid cooling system is easier to ensure that the battery works at a comfortable temperature. Compared with the air cooling system, the battery life will be extended by more than 20%. In terms of the overall life cycle, the investment in liquid cooling is less.
4. Conclusion
In general, liquid cooling vs air cooling, the air-cooled system has the advantages of small initial investment, low maintenance cost, and different maintenance, and is more suitable for small civilian or commercial battery thermal management.Â
However, liquid cooling has gradually become the mainstream battery cooling method in large-scale ground power stations and other fields with large capacity and high energy ratio.

This article introduces the new technology of flywheel energy storage, and expounds its definition, technology, characteristics and other aspects.

In this article, we’ll discuss the importance of UPS energy storage and how it can significantly enhance power backup capabilities. Exploring the features and benefits of UPS energy storage from now.

This article summarizes top 10 manufacturers of global energy storage batteries. They are CATL, BYD, EVE, REPT,HTHIUM, Great Power, Envision Energy, CALB, GOTION HIGH-TECH, Ganfeng Lithium.







+86 – 18925002618




